Is Butcher Box A Good Deal? Here’s My Honest Review!

Here’s my honest Butcher Box review!

For years I have been asking “Is Butcher Box a good deal?”  I kept hearing so many people say how awesome Butcher Box is and I have been wanting to try it out for myself!  I finally got my wish when they contacted me and offered to send me a box to review.  Talk about a dream come true!  I know a lot of you out there have probably heard about Butcher Box, but have been unsure if it’s right for you or not.  Today, I’m sharing my honest review of Butcher Box to help you make that important decision.

This article contains affiliate links.  I will be compensated from purchases made from links in this article.

What is Butcher Box?

First things first, Butcher Box is a meat delivery service that offers 100% grass-fed, grass-finished beef; free-range organic chicken; heritage-breed pork, wild-caught Alaskan sockeye salmon, and more!!  These high quality meat products will be sent straight to your doorstep.

But!  The thing that makes Butcher Box most special is their commitment to raising animals in a humane way, with no added hormones or antibiotics, EVER!

Their mission is centered around making the lives of farmers and animals better, and helping the consumer gain access to a higher quality meat.  (win, win!)

How Does It Work?

Butcher Box works very similar to other subscription services.

First, choose your box from the 5 different box choices.

The box choices include:

Custom Box Classic

• 9-14 lbs.
• $159/month

The Custom Box Classic gives you the option of choosing your own cuts of beef, pork or chicken.

Custom Box Big

• 18-26 lbs.
• $288/month

The Custom Box Big gives you the same option of choosing your own cuts of beef pork or chicken as the classic custom box.  The Big box is just…bigger!

The Basic Box

• 7-7.5 lbs.
• $99/month

The Basic Box includes high quality beef, organic chicken, and pork.

The Mixed Box

• 8.5-11 lbs
• $137/month

The Mixed Box is the box that I ordered.  It came with high quality selection of beef, chicken and pork.  The amount and exact cuts will vary month to month, but we were very pleased with our box.

The Beef and Pork Box

• 8-11 lbs
• $137/month

The Beef and Pork Box will give you a variety of both beef and pork cut meats.  You will find anything from tenderloin to steaks to ground beef and more.

The Beef and Chicken Box

• 8.5-11 lbs
• $137/month

In the Beef and Chicken Box you will be treated to a selection of both chicken and beef meat cuts.

The All Beef Box

• 8-10 lbs
• $137/month

In the All Beef Box you will receive beef cuts ranging from ground beef to roasts and steaks.  Yum!

How Often Will I Receive My Box?

You have three options for delivery frequency.  You can choose to have your box delivered monthly, every 6 weeks, or every other month.  However, you can cancel or pause delivery at any time at no extra cost.  So, if you are needing a break, just put it on pause and continue whenever is convenient for you.

What Makes Butcher Box Special?

Butcher Box is special because of their commitment to delivering high quality products to their customers and their mission of raising animals in a humane way.  Here are a few other highlights about Butcher Box and their animals.

Beef: 

• 100% grass fed
• Pasture raised

Chicken: 

• Free range organic
• No antibiotics ever
• No added hormones (Federal regulations prohibit the use of hormones or steroids in poultry)

Pork:

• All vegetarian feed
• Humanely raised
• Bacon has no nitrates or nitrites and does not contain added sugar

How Is The Box Shipped?

All of the meat shipped from Butcher Box is frozen and individually vacuum packed.  It will be shipped in a box with insulation and dry ice if needed.  Your meat will arrive frozen, cold and ready for the fridge or freezer.

What Came In My Box?

Alright, now let’s get to the good stuff!  Here is all the nitty gritty about receiving my first box.

I wanted to try out the Mixed Box and was really excited to see everything that I got.  In this box I received:

• 2 lbs of Ground Beef
• 2 NY Strip Steaks
• 4 Top Sirloin Steaks
• 1lb of Whole Pork Tenderloin
• 3lbs of Boneless Skinless Chicken Breast

The meat was still frozen and cold when arriving on my doorstep, just the way we like it!  I also loved the packaging!

How Did It Taste?

The meat we received was so yummy and tender.  It was delicious!  In all honesty, I usually buy fairly cheap meat and we could definitely tell a difference in quality from Butcher Box and the cheaper variety.

My husband even made a point to tell me how much he enjoyed it more than the kind I usually buy.  (hint noted hubby!)

Can I Cancel My Subscription?

Canceling your Butcher Box subscription is super quick and easy.  You can cancel anytime with no charge.  Or, consider just putting your subscription on hold for a few months.

Putting it on hold is a great way to take a break if your freezer is getting to full or your budget is getting tight.

What I Liked About Butcher Box

The Convenience

Butcher Box is about as convenient as it gets!  The ordering process was quick, delivery painless and I didn’t even have to leave my house.  As a busy mom, I am all about making life a little more convenient.

The Taste

We truly loved the taste of Butcher Box meat.  Everything was tender, juicy and delicious!

The Quality

You just can’t get better quality than Butcher Box.  I love that their animals are raised in a humane way.  And, I love that the meat is fresh, organic with no added hormones.

It’s important to me what my family puts in their body, and I know I can trust Butcher Box in this.

What I Did NOT Like About Butcher Box

The Cost

Butcher Box averages about $6/per dinner.  I do not think this is an extreme cost, considering the quality of the product, but it is more than I usually spend on my meat products.

However, like I said before, I usually buy much lesser quality….and we can taste the difference.

Will I Order From Butcher Box Again?

Absolutely!  I will order from Butcher Box again!

After tasting this product, and enjoying the convenience of it being shipped right to my front door, I definitely want to start ordering from them with an every other month subscription.

I decided (to help offset the cost) to keep a mix of higher quality Butcher Box meat and lower quality grocery store meat in our freezer at all times.  It’s a good way to get the best of both worlds.

Try Butcher Box For Yourself

If you want to try Butcher Box out for yourself click here and start enjoying some delicious meat!

Pin this article for future reference:

I hope this answered your question, Is Butcher Box A Good Deal?